Enforcement policy

Details

Policy owed by: Building Safety

Tier: 2 (Policy)

Does policy apply to any of the following groups in addition to colleagues: Members, Volunteers, Cadets, Contractors? : Yes, Members, Volunteers

Version number: V1

Related Tier 2 Policies: Risk Based Intervention Programme Policy,  Primary Authority Partnership Scheme (PAS) Policy

Organisational aim

This policy establishes a fair and proportionate regulatory framework that drives up long-term fire safety standards across Kent. By carrying out proportionate and consistent enforcement ensures that buildings across our communities are safe, establishing a clear link between daily regulatory activity and our ultimate aim of saving lives and reducing harm.

Introduction

This policy sets out the service that businesses and others being regulated by the Kent Fire and Rescue Authority (the Service) can expect from its regulatory and enforcement function and its appointed inspectors. It goes some way to satisfying the Regulators’ Code by committing the Service and appointed Regulators to the principles of good enforcement with the assistance of effective procedures and clear guidance. The primary function of the regulatory part of the Service is to achieve safety in case of fire in premises to which The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, as amended (FSO) applies.  

The Services Enforcement Policy has been prepared considering the principles of best practice recommended by Government for regulatory bodies. Listed below are the primary guidance and Legislation: 

  • The Regulators Code 
  • Enforcement Management Model (EMM) issued by the HSE 
  • The Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Act 2008 
  • The Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006 
  • The Legislative and Regulatory Reform (Regulatory Functions) Order 2007 
  • The Environment and Safety Information Act 1988 
  • The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, as amended. 
  • The Licensing Act 2003 
  • Human Rights Act1998
  • Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984
  • Enforcement Concordat 
  • Environment Protection Act 1990

Service policy

Principles of Enforcement 

Fire safety regulation is founded on the principle that people should be kept safe in case of fire.  Kent FRS regulates to help secure this safety and through regulation, the Service aims to provide a consistently high-quality service to those we regulate.  Our regulatory activity generally extends to premises in which there is a trade, business or other undertaking that falls within the scope of the FSO. 

Non-compliance with fire safety law will mean that in our view, people are at risk in case of fire.  Where we identify people at risk, we will respond proportionately to that risk; taking account of the likelihood and severity of the risk in line with Our aim and objectives.

The Service believes in firm but fair enforcement of fire safety standards.  This is achieved by: 

  • proportionally applying the law to secure safety. 
  • being consistent in our approach to regulation. 
  • targeting our resources and enforcement action on the highest risk. 
  • being transparent about how we operate and regulate.
  • being accountable for our actions.

The Service will have regard to the Regulators Code when developing the policies and procedures that guide our regulatory activities. We will encourage and promote fire safety while minimising the associated costs of providing safety from fire.

The Service believe that by fostering good relationships with our business community and by working with them, we can improve public safety, business resilience, and can remove any unnecessary burdens of complying with fire safety law.

The Service will endeavour to engage with the business community, to seek their views about our policies and practices.  

In the most serious cases of danger in case of fire, we will take immediate and decisive action to secure safety, for example by serving a Prohibition Notice that may restrict the use of part of or all of the premises.

The way we approach regulation.

In accordance with the Regulators Code, the Service takes enforcement action (and imposes sanctions and penalties) to:

  • change the behaviour that led to non-compliance.
  • change societal attitudes to the risks from fire.
  • eliminate financial gain or benefit from putting people at risk in case of fire.
  • exercise a proportionate response to the nature of the offence and the harm caused.
  • restore safety to premises where fire safety risks were found.
  • encourage fire safety to be secured in future.
  • impose an appropriate sanction, which can include penalty through the courts (and the public stigma that should be associated with a criminal conviction).

Helping those we regulate

The Service will help those responsible for delivering safety in case of fire (responsible persons and duty holders) to understand what is expected of them and what they should expect from the Service. 

Legal requirements will be clearly distinguished from best practice or non-statutory fire safety advice.  We will publish any guidance and advice in a clear, accessible, concise, format using media appropriate to the target audience, in plain language.

Risk Based Intervention Programme

The Service operates a Risk Based Intervention programme (RBIP) to drive its audits, inspection and compliance. This system utilises data and guidance from the Home Office and the National Fire Chief’s Council (NFCC) together with local intelligence and knowledge and incorporates local risk priorities identified from trends in location, types of fire and assessment of vulnerability of groups in local areas within the service area. From time to time, and particularly if any significant changes are proposed, the Service will consult regulated entities on its methodology through consultation on its Community Risk Management Plan

Audits, inspection and compliance checks will be undertaken by Fire Safety

Regulators on the basis of the Service’s RBIP. The greatest audit and inspection effort will be allocated to premises where a compliance breach would pose a serious risk to the safety of relevant persons and the Service has reason to believe that there is a high likelihood of noncompliance with the law.

Partnership Working

The Service has entered into a number of agreements with other enforcing authorities to provide clarification about which authority takes the lead for particular premises types where the enforcement regimes overlap. To minimise audit and inspection burdens for regulated entities, the Service will continue to seek to develop, engage in, and foster partnerships working with other enforcers and other stakeholder groups.

When serious fire safety concerns are raised about a property which results in customers having to leave their homes, the Service will work closely with the Local Authority Housing teams to ensure alternative accommodation and support is provided. This process limits the negative impact on people in the community.  

Enforcement Options

Where fire is likely and / or the consequences of fire pose a hazard to people, it may become necessary for the Service to take action (against the responsible person / duty holder) to reduce the risk. The Service adheres to the HSE -Enforcement Management Model when formal action is required to be taken. 

Inspectors utilise this process when determining enforcement action. Such judgement is made in accordance with Better Regulation principles which are in accordance with the Regulators Code.

The service has a wide range of enforcement action available to use that includes:

  • Educate and inform.
  • Informal action (Notification of Deficiencies).
  • Statutory Notice (including Enforcement, Alterations and Prohibition).
  • Referral to other agencies.
  • Simple Caution and Prosecution through the Criminal Justice System

Enforcement Management Model (EMM)

The Service will use discretion in deciding when to enforce. The HSE - Enforcement Management Model provides a logical system that helps Regulators to make enforcement decisions on when and what enforcement action may be appropriate. Judgement is made in accordance with Better Regulation principles which are in accordance with the Regulators Code.

Principles of Enforcement Action

In assessing necessary and proportionate enforcement action, the application of the Evidence Test and the Public Interest Test will be applied throughout the enforcement and any subsequent investigation process. consideration will be given but not limited to:

  1. Seriousness of the Offence 
  • The more serious the offence, the more likely it is that a prosecution will be required. 
  • Seriousness must be assessed by considering both the culpability (see below) of the suspect and the harm or potential harm caused. 

b) Level of Culpability 

Prosecution is more likely where the suspect’s culpability is high. Relevant considerations include: 

  • the level of involvement in the offending; 
  • whether the offence was deliberate, planned, or repeated; 
  • whether the suspect benefitted financially or otherwise; 
  • any history of previous non‑compliance, convictions, or enforcement action; 
  • whether the behaviour is ongoing or escalating; 
  • the suspect’s age and maturity. 

Culpability may be reduced where the suspect was coerced, exploited, or compelled, particularly where they are also the victim of related offending. 

Mental or physical ill health or disability may also reduce culpability in some cases. This must be balanced against public safety considerations and the seriousness of the offence. 

c) Harm to the Victim and Victim Circumstances 

The impact on the victim is a key public interest consideration. 

Prosecution is more likely where: 

  • the victim is vulnerable or perceived to be vulnerable; 
  • a position of trust or authority was abused; 
  • the victim was serving the public at the time of the offence; 
  • the offence involved targeting or exploitation; 
  • the behaviour was motivated by hostility or prejudice. 

Victim views about the impact of the offence should be considered, but decisions must reflect the wider public interest. The Service does not act on behalf of victims in the same way as a private solicitor. 

Where prosecution may adversely affect the victim’s health or wellbeing, this must be carefully weighed alongside the seriousness of the offence and the availability of protective or special measures. 

d) Age and Maturity of the Suspect 

Significant weight must be attached where the suspect is under 18. 

Consideration must be given to: 

  • the best interests and welfare of the child or young person; 
  • whether prosecution would have a disproportionate impact on future prospects; 
  • the aim of preventing re‑offending. 

Maturity should be considered alongside age, recognising that young adults may still lack full maturity. 

As a general principle, the younger the suspect, the less likely prosecution is required. However, prosecution may still be appropriate where the offence is serious, alternatives are unavailable, or there is a relevant history of offending. 

e) Impact on the Community 

The greater the impact of the offence on the community, the more likely prosecution will be required. 

Community impact may relate to: 

  • public safety and confidence; 
  • the prevalence of similar offending; 
  • harm to a specific group, profession, or local area. 

f) Proportionality 

Prosecution must be a proportionate response to the offending. 

This includes considering: 

  • the seriousness of the offence and level of risk posed; 
  • the likely outcome of court proceedings; 
  • whether alternative enforcement options would adequately protect the public and secure compliance. 

Proportionality does not mean avoiding prosecution because a case is difficult, time‑consuming, or resource‑intensive. 
 

g) Protection of Information and Sources 

Care must be taken where prosecution could risk: 

  • exposing sensitive sources of information; 
  • undermining ongoing investigations; 
  • impacting national security or other protected interests. 

In every case, when we require action to remedy unsafe conditions, we will explain the nature of the unsafe conditions to those responsible and will confirm the same in writing.

Because, subject to any letter or notice we give, work must be done to improve or secure the safety of people in case of fire; we will agree reasonable timescales within which the work must be completed that are agreed with those responsible.

The Service will offer responsible persons and duty holders information and advice both verbally and / or in writing. This will include an explanation of why any specified work is necessary and a time period within which the specified work should be completed. Educating, informing and advising responsible persons and duty holders about their duties under fire safety legislation will form a fundamental element of our enforcement regime. The Service will fulfil its obligation under section 6(2) of the Fire and Rescue Services Act 2004 to give on request, advice on fire safety free of charge.

Fire Safety law gives power to warranted inspectors to take samples of dangerous materials or extracts of recorded safety information and documents.  When request materials or documents we will provide an appropriate receipt.

In the most serious of cases we will gather information and conduct an investigation to prepare for a prosecution. The decision to prosecute a case will be taken by those with authority to do so in accordance with our Scheme of Delegations.

All our colleagues that make enforcement decisions will be required to follow the Regulators Code

When the Service takes enforcement action, we will discuss what is required to achieve safety for relevant persons with the responsible person / duty holder (taking into account the circumstances of the case, if they have been explained to us).

The Service will clearly explain any advice, required actions or decisions taken at the time of our visit and will be willing to discuss such matters on any future occasion to ensure those responsible have clarity of what must be done.

Our letters and notices will provide details in writing of what must be done and how to appeal against any of our regulatory decisions. Our letters and notices will also explain what will happen next, especially if you do not undertake the work. Our website has details of how to complain about our conduct, contact us

We encourage those responsible for providing safety in case of fire to contact us, especially if there are any questions or comments about our regulatory activity. We will also maintain regular communication (where required) until safety has been provided.

Statutory Enforcement, Prohibition / Restriction and Alterations Notices

Formal action will take the form of serving a Notice (Alterations, Enforcement, and/or Prohibition Notices).  Formal action will be taken when the consequences of fire are such that people are likely to be harmed, suffer serious injury or death. It can require specific action to be taken or certain activities to cease.  

Notices specify the problem and will either require a remedy as determined by officers or (if the legislation allows) may allow for other action with an equivalent remedial effect. In most cases there is a right of appeal against a Notice. Where there is a right of appeal, advice on the appeal mechanism will be set out in writing to the person on whom the notice is served. 

Where a Notice requires changes to a premises in which another enforcing body has a statutory interest, the Service will, so far as is reasonably practicable, consult with such bodies as can reasonably be identified before serving the notice. Any such consultation will not release the person on whom the notice is served from their statutory obligation to consult relevant bodies in respect of works they will undertake as a result of a notice. Any failure by the Service to consult with any particular body or person will not invalidate any notice served under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, as amended.

The following notices are available for use: 

Alterations Notices (Article 29)

Where a reasonable known change to premises or to the use of premises could result in a significant increase in the risks to people on the premises, we may serve an Alterations Notice, which requires the responsible person/duty holder to notify us, before making that known change.

Enforcement Notices (Article 30)

Enforcement Notices require improvements in safety and will point out that people are at risk in case of fire; where in the building they are located; what has led to them being put at risk, as well as what should be done to provide safety and how to prevent the same danger from recurring.  

Enforcement Notices include a reasonable period of time for safety to be put in place.  Failure to respond to a formal Notice can result in escalation to an investigation for prosecution. 

Restriction / Prohibition Notices (Article 31) 

Where immediate action is considered necessary to keep people safe from fire, (such action will be considered where conditions are found that constitute a serious risk to life or injury to persons in the event of fire), a Prohibition Notice, which can prohibit or restrict the use of premises, can be served.  An explanation of why such action is required will be given at the time and confirmed in writing.  Whereas a Prohibition Notice requires action to remove imminent and immediate risks in case of fire, an Enforcement Notice might also be served to deal with less imminent risks in case of fire.

Referral to other Agencies

Where other Health and Safety enforcing authorities have a regulatory interest in a particular premises, details will be forwarded to the appropriate agency, for example if apparently dangerous conditions or practices (not related to fire) are noted in a workplace.

Simple Caution and Prosecution

There are a number of offences that can be committed under fire safety law.  Among the foremost of these are failure to comply with a formal notice and failing to provide safety in case of fire to such extent that one or more people are put at risk of death or serious injury in case of fire.

Through prosecution and Simple Cautions these legal actions are important ways to bring to account those responsible for alleged legal offences.  Where appropriate, we will use one of these measures. The Service will use discretion, legal advice and CMB agreement as part of its decision making process in deciding whether to bring a prosecution. 

The decision to prosecute is a serious step. Fair and effective prosecution forms a legitimate element of the Service’s strategy to reduce the risk of death and injury in regulated premises by enforcing fire safety law. Any prosecution has serious implications for all involved – including the person prosecuted, casualties, witnesses, and Service’s personnel. 

All enforcement activities, including investigations and formal actions, will always be conducted in compliance with the statutory powers of the officer and all other relevant legislation, including but not limited to the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996, the Human Rights Act 1998, and the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, and in accordance with any formal procedures and codes of practice made under this legislation so far as they relate to the regulatory activity of the Service.

Failure to Comply with Requirements

Rights of, and routes to appeal, will be clearly set out in writing and issued with our letters.

We can withdraw Alterations, Enforcement and Prohibition Notices at any time, but they will generally be deemed to be in force until such time as the notice is complied with, appealed, withdrawn or cancelled by the court.

A failure to comply with an Alterations, Enforcement or Prohibition Notice constitutes an offence and may result in prosecution.

Publicity

The Service will consider publicising the serving of a Prohibition Notice or any conviction, which could serve to draw attention to the need to comply with fire safety requirements or deter anyone tempted to disregard their duties under fire safety law.  

Public Register

The Service will enter details of certain notices (called “relevant notices”) into a register to which the public have access.  (In accordance with the Environment and Safety Information Act 1988).  The register can be accessed via the services website (Public Register). 

Other Duties of The Service 

In addition to its primary duties under the Fire Safety Order (FSO), the Service also holds statutory responsibilities for fire safety under other relevant legislation. This includes enforcing specific provisions within the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, as well as fulfilling its roles as a regulator and statutory consultee under the Building Safety Act 2022.

Wherever appropriate, the Service will endeavour to utilise the FSO as its primary enforcement tool. Where the FSO is not the applicable legislative mechanism, or where overlapping jurisdictions exist, the Service will work collaboratively with or refer matters to the relevant enforcing authority (such as the Building Safety Regulator or the Health and Safety Executive)

Equality and Diversity

All enforcement decisions will be fair, independent and objective.  When formal enforcement action is necessary, each case will be considered on its merits.  Enforcement outcomes will not be influenced by any of the protected characteristics of the people involved.  Such decisions will not be affected by improper or undue pressure from any source.

Although the protected characteristics of those involved do not influence the enforcement outcome, it is acknowledged that our enforcement activity may have a positive impact in relation to improving fire safety standards in certain premises. An example of this would be elderly residents living in a residential care premises who may require mobility assistance to evacuate.  As part of the audit process, the specific needs of these occupants would be taken into account and where appropriate, additional control measures identified and implemented. 

Data Protection

The Service will comply with the principles of the Data Protection Policy governing the use of personal data received or obtained and will respect the rights and freedoms of those individuals when processing their details. 

Details are available on request contact us

Relevant Legislation and Codes of Practice

All enforcement activities, including investigations and formal actions, will always be conducted in compliance with the statutory powers of the officer and all other relevant legislation, including but not limited to:

  • Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984
  • Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996
  • Human Rights Act 1998

And in accordance with any formal procedures and codes of practice made under this legislation so far as they relate to the regulatory activity of the Service.